Last week Tim Montgomerie made a particularly cogent point about how the British media has been reporting the eurozone crisis.
In light of the increasingly important role of Angela Merkel and the German government, the ConHome editor implores: ‘can we talk about Germany without resorting to World War II imagery?’
This is a question that merits considerable thought. Have our newspapers and commentators been justified in their suspicion of German motives over the last few weeks? Can any ‘imagery’ relating to her colourful history be deemed merely as harmless and jocular? Or has the British media been guilty of treating Germany with a tasteless lack of respect and, as Montgomerie claims, of acting like Basil Fawlty?
There is some evidence to suggest that the British government should be casting a wary eye toward Berlin.
Documents leaked over the last few days have revealed that the German foreign office has been drawing up plans for a new body that would allow Brussels to take control of struggling eurozone economies. Boris Johnson reasonably argues that the events of recent weeks have damaged democracy in Greece and Italy; it seems Slovenia and Slovakia could be the next nations to cede sovereignty. Flagrant scaremongering aside, there is nonetheless something credible in fears that an entrenched and complete fiscal union will leave Germany in a more influential position than ourselves.
But does that really equate to claiming, as Simon Heffer did in last Thursday’s Daily Mail, that Germany is attempting to establish a ‘Fourth Reich’ that will eventually ‘conquer Europe’?
Such rhetoric has become a worrying norm in certain circles over the last few weeks. Another piece in the Mail, by Richard Littlejohn, was accompanied by a cartoon entitled ‘Springtime for Merkel’, depicting the German Chancellor as Adolf Hitler. The Telegraph’s Simon Winder notes that ‘Germany’s attempts to dominate Europe militarily ended in utter moral and physical disaster’, going on to make the comparison with today’s situation, or as he sees it: ‘Germany’s more recent attempt to dominate Europe’. The job of chief-provocateur was left to a politician; UKIP leader Nigel Farage told his MEP colleagues that ‘we are now living in a German-dominated Europe…something that those before us paid a heavy price in blood to prevent’.
This imagery could simply be dismissed as banter; a playful exchange between the more eccentric members of the British political class and their German counterparts.
But surely the words of Heffer, Winder, Farage et al are more than that. Europe faces an incredibly grave economic crisis, one that will not be solved cheap and immature sniping. Perhaps those spouting the Second World War rhetoric would be best advised to forget the playground name-calling and focus on finding some answers to the problems we face.
Our newspapers should resemble a wealth of diverse and constructive analysis; during many past crises it has been the media that has steered the way towards the solution.
We don’t want Basil Fawlty at the helm.
Alexander Wickham is a freelance journalist who writes for the New Internationalist, the Adam Smith Institute and the Huffington Post, amongst others. He tweets at @Wickham_A











Comments
John / November 22 2011 4:52pm
Farage's comment can be true without comparing Merkel to Hitler.
As Dan Hannan is oft saying, the Germans are doing everything they can to not be like the Nazis and take over Europe.
... but in doing so, they've ended up exactly where they didn't want to be but can't see the right way out.
Mark / November 22 2011 7:19pm
With apologies to Flanders and Swann:
Heil Merkel!
This old gal, she played one,
She played knick knack – meet at Cannes
Riesling, Kabinett, Trockenbeer und Hock
I’ll ignore referendum lock
This old gal, Lisbon too,
She told Sarko what to do
Ireland Portugal Italy and Spain,
She came rolling home again
This old gal, she played drei
Frankfurt bankers will stand by
Euro governments call me if you please
We’ll make up our own treaties
This old gal, she played four
Choose EU or civil war
She’s the president – step right into line
Referendum – Nein! Nein! Nein!
This old gal, she played five
Eurozone she will contrive
Puppet governments sing the Ode to Joy
Greece and Italy be a good boy
This old gal, she played six
Deutsch und Englisch – they don’t mix
Frankreich, Benelux, Italy and me
That’s my Market recipe
This old gal, sieb’n und acht,
Nun wir haben alle Macht
Kiss kiss Cameron ratified in Bonn
One old gal goes on and on
This old gal, nine and ten
She’ll play Nick till God knows when
Pilsner Kellerbier Dunkelbier und Bock
This old gal thinks she’s the rock.
Sam / November 22 2011 8:46pm
What on earth must everyone else think of us when we're still harking back to the second world war. It is the mail I suppose
Blindfolded Monkey / November 23 2011 12:52am
The Germans may well take over Europe but it wasn't their idea this time. They are being dragged into it because they are the only ones who have been able to competently manage their own affairs.
Acting / November 23 2011 3:07am
Bring out the artist in you by showcasing your talent in the field of acting with Drakebook. Skills like acting that requires a passion to succeed & the in-depth observations into life & its happenings around you bringing you the right frame of expression on your face, tone, pitch, body language & everything
scottspeig / November 23 2011 3:01pm
Those that refuse to learn from history will replay history.
While I think the imagery used pushes the argument away as people may not listen, it is true that there have been 2 failed attempts to unite European countries together with Germany at the head. To dismiss the 3rd attempt puts all at risk.
Is it pure coincidence that it is Germany yet again that is trying to unite Europe? I personally don't think so, although I don't think they went out of their way to get it either. But since we as a nation have fought so hard against a dominant country in Europe (as it would tip the balance too far), it would be foolhardy to now push it forward.
Also, removing democracy in the European countries is recipe for civil unrest.