The dust is beginning to settle after the scrum caused by MPs in Portcullis House yesterday lunchtime, all desperate to get their hands on a copy of the Boundary Commission’s proposals for changing constituency boundaries in England. While there is still a lengthy consultation process to come, the impact this review is likely to have on the futures of sitting MPs is beginning to become clear. Many in Westminster today still seem to be stunned by the sheer scale of the changes proposed – of England’s existing 533 constituencies, only 77 are entirely unaffected.
A number of senior figures in the cabinet and shadow cabinet may face difficult re-election campaigns or the prospect of having to battle other sitting MPs from their own party just in order to be re-selected, but in actual fact most of the big names seem to have fared alright. David Cameron and Ed Miliband are both among the lucky 77 whose constituencies are due to remain exactly as they are. Although George Osborne’s Tatton and Nick Clegg’s Sheffield Hallam constituencies have been axed, neither man is likely to be seriously worried. Tatton has been almost completely incorporated within the new constituency of Northwich, whilst Sheffield Hallam has been split fairly evenly between two new constituencies – Sheffield South West and Sheffield West & Penistone – both of which look likely to contain Lib Dem majorities, judging by the results of the 2010 council elections.
Other rumoured re-selection battles that now appear to be avoidable include a potential clash between Ed Balls and Hilary Benn, whose neighbouring constituencies in West Yorkshire have both been axed, but have been replaced by two brand new constituencies that are both likely to contain large Labour majorities. Another tasty prospect was the possibility of the business secretary, Vince Cable, going head-to-head with Tory pin-up boy, Zac Goldsmith, in the newly created Richmond and Twickenham constituency. But in fact, much of Cable’s constituency has been absorbed into another new seat – Teddington and Hanworth – so he may decide to stand there instead.
Not everyone has been so lucky though. The work and pensions secretary, Iain Duncan Smith, could be in trouble, as his constituency is re-drawn to incorporate three new strong Labour wards. And Ken Clarke certainly faces confusion as his constituency appears to have been slashed, with wards from it being scattered among no fewer than four different proposed seats.
In South London, there may be an intriguing battle between two rising stars of the Labour Party – Sadiq Khan and Chuka Umunna – whose constituencies (Tooting and Streatham) have been combined, with no obvious alternative seat for either emerging. And the newly merged seat of Kendal and Penrith may be the scene of a major bust-up between coalition partners, as Lib Dem President, Tim Farron, may find himself running against sitting Tory MP, Rory Stewart.
But overall, it is those further down the pecking order who appear most likely to lose out if the proposed changes go through. With 31 seats in England due to disappear completely, and given that the 2010 intake included a higher than usual number of new faces, it is highly likely that a number of political careers may be cut short. And all backbenchers, unless they are in the lucky 77, will be worried. There seems to be widespread suspicion that high-profile MPs will be parachuted into safe seats by the party leaderships, while backbenchers lose out. It remains an open question whether this will lead to a major bout of indiscipline across all the parliamentary parties, with rebelliously-minded backbenchers who have nothing to lose causing a major headache for the whips. The answer may become clearer in the coming days. All eyes will certainly be on the 1922 committee when it meets tomorrow.
Spare a thought also for the hundreds of constituency agents, the unsung heroes of British politics, many of them with decades of experience in a single constituency, who will suddenly be faced with the challenge of acquainting themselves with the political geography of a raft of new wards. These proposals will be causing headaches not just in Westminster, but across the country.
The full list of the unaffected constituencies and their sitting MPs:
Congleton – Fiona Bruce
Crewe and Nantwich – Edward Timpson
St Helens North – Dave Watts
St Helens South and Whiston – shaun woodward
Bury South - Ivan Lewis
Wigan – Lisa Nandy
West Lancashire – Rosie Cooper
Cambridge – Julian Huppert
Central Suffolk and North Ipswich – Dan Poulter
Ipswich- Ben Gummer
Norwich South – Simon Wright
Suffolk Coastal – Therese Coffey
Waveney – Peter Aldous
Colchester – Bob Russell
Thurrock – Jackie Doyle-Price
Gainsborough – Edward Leigh
Grantham and Stanford – Nick Boles
South Holland and The Deepings – John Hayes
Ashfield – Gloria de Piero
Corby – Louise Mensch
Harborough – Edward Garnier
Leicester East – Keith Vaz
Leicester South – Jon Ashworth
Loughborough – Nicky Morgan
Rutland and Melton – Alan Duncan
Bethnal Green and Bow – Rushanara Ali
Poplar and Limehouse – Jim Fitzpatrick
Chipping Barnet – Theresa Villiers
Hendon – Matthew Offord
Bracknell – Philip Lee
Maidenhead – Theresa May
Newbury – Richard Benyon
Reading East – Rob Wilson
Reading West – Alok Sharma
Wokingham – John Redwood
Eastbourne – Stephen Lloyd
Hastings and Rye – Amber Rudd
Sittingbourne and Sheppey – Gordon Henderson
Beaconsfield – Dominic Grieve
Gosport – Caroline Dinenage
Wantage – Ed Vaizey
Witney – David Cameron
Epsom and Ewell – Chris Grayling
Esher and Walton – Dominic Raab
South West Surrey – Jeremy Hunt
East Worthing and Shoreham – Tim Loughton
Worthing West – Peter Bottomley
Exeter – Ben Bradshaw
North Devon – Nicholas Harvey
Torbay – Adrian Sanders
North Swindon – Justin Tomlinson
South Swindon – Robert Buckland
South Dorset – Richard Drax
West Dorset – Oliver Letwin
Cheltenham – Martin Horwood
Tewkesbury – Lawrence Robertson
Bristol South – Dawn Primarolo
Bristol North West – Charlotte Leslie
North Somerset – Liam Fox
Weston-Super-Mare – John Penrose
North Shropshire – Owen Paterson
Shrewsbury and Atcham – Daniel Kawczynski
Wyre Forest – Mark Garnier
Broxbourne - Charles Walker
Burton – Andrew Griffiths
Cannock Chase – Aidan Burley
South Staffordshire – Gavin Williamson
Coventry South – Jim Cunningham
Coventry North West – Geoffrey Robinson
Coventry North East – Bob Ainsworth
Rother Valley – Kevin Barron
Scarborough and Whitby – Robert Goodwill
Doncaster Central – Rosie Winterton
Doncaster North – Ed Miliband
Don Valley – Caroline Flint









Comments
Tim Mullen / September 13 2011 2:02pm
Very technical point for the sake of accuracy, Leicester South's MP is no longer Sir Peter Soulsby (he resigned after becoming Elected Mayor of Leicester in May) but is Jon Ashworth.